Saltburn's Actual Twist Is Essential

"Unlike you, I actually know how to work."

I recently watched Jordan Theresa's YouTube video (link) in which she explained why she didn't like Saltburn and one of the massive sticking points she had was the mid-film twist centred around Oliver Quick, and how she felt this almost entirely ruined any class commentary or themes the film had. I really enjoyed the video, and broadly agreed that Saltburn was underwhelming, but bizarrely, Theresa's analysis actually made me see the twist in a far more positive light and greatly improved my general feelings towards the film, even if I'm unconvinced my interpretation matches Emerald Fennel's intentions.

The twist, and here's the obligatory but surely unnecessary spoiler warning, is that our working-class half-orphan only child with a drug-addicted mum actually belongs to a middle-class family, which consists of two alive and well parents and several siblings. Our ultimate underdog attempting to overcome the terrible circumstances life has inflicted upon him is nothing more than a liar; his tragic background a concoction to make him seem more interesting. Despite the entire film being solely from Oliver's perspective, in this moment we're in Felix's shoes, finally having the wool removed from our eyes and seeing Oliver for who he really is.

The twist is presented as a colossal one and seeks to recontextualise all of Oliver's previous actions. We'd already been shown that Oliver was, to put it bluntly, a bit of a freak, but his dad had recently died and his mum was a drug addict so who were we to judge too harshly? Licking the inside of a bathroom plug hole is unpleasant, but is more likely to cause harm to Oliver than anyone else. With this new information, however, Oliver is suddenly the villain of the story. There is no evil scheme behind Felix's decision to invite Oliver to stay. The Cattons are good honest people trying to help someone who they believe is in need. Any warmth shown to Oliver is genuine, but any appreciation returned by Oliver is dishonest. Or at least, that's Fennel's intention?

It's only after this twist that the film starts showing you where it's going. Cattons start dying by various different means and it's revealed that Oliver has spent the entire film enacting a plan he'd devised to steal the Cattons' wealth, something he achieves with aplomb.

In the film's final scene, we finally get to see Oliver's up until now conveniently obscured penis, as he celebrates his triumph with a fully nude celebratory dance around his mansion to Sophie Ellis-Bextor's Murder on the Dance Floor, leaving us all asking the same question. Could Oliver hear that music or was he dancing around naked in silence?

Theresa, whose interpretation I consider far more important than Emerald Fennel's intentions, states that one of the reasons the twist doesn't work is that Oliver, as is the case for all middle-class people, is far closer to being working class than he is to being upper class. Oliver went from a manipulative creep whose class and wealth were nowhere near that of the Cattons to a manipulative creep whose class and wealth were nowhere near that of the Cattons. Other than to shock the audience, what purpose does the twist actually serve?

I completely agree that by the vast majority of measurable metrics, the middle class are closer to the working class than they are to the upper class, and Theresa's explanation about the relationship between the classes and the existence of the middle class in the UK is really interesting, but I don't think it justifies a complete dismissal of Saltburn's twist.

The crucial difference between the working class and the middle class is vulnerability and desperation. The working class typically exist paycheque to paycheque, with no financial security or real means to save. It can be an active fight to consistently put food on the table. It's largely impossible to own property, and ever-increasing rental payments mean that the prospect of homelessness is a legitimate one for many in the working class. Obviously, there are still different levels of wealth within the working class, but I consider the crucial factor separating them from the middle class to be the lack of comfort which can only be afforded by financial security.

Generally speaking, the working class don't want to be upper class, they just want to be comfortable. Their difficulties are so suffocating and reality so unmoving that any dreams of wealth on a level comparable with the upper class are nothing more than fairy tales. The upper class inhabit a different plane of existence to the working class and any serious ambitions to make that big a jump in social status are met with laughter akin to the Evil Stepmother mocking Cinderella for believing Prince Charming could ever be in love with her.

As Theresa explains far better than I could, the middle class was manufactured to break up the proletariat class and turn it against itself, something that worked perfectly. The politicians sold the idea that the middle class had more in common with the upper class than the working class, that they were the hard workers and the earners and the working class were the lazy scroungers. Plenty of members of the middle class bought in and turned against the working class, looking down on them with resentment in an attempt to associate themselves with the far more desirable upper class. Whilst the jump from middle class to upper class was still practically impossible, it was advertised to the middle class as not just an acceptable ambition, but an encouraged ambition.

So why is this so relevant to the twist of Saltburn? The twist doesn't just reveal that Oliver is pretending to be a member of the working class, it reveals that he's mocking them. His tales of drug-dealing fathers and drug-addicted mothers. His inability to afford a round of shots. He's using his perception of a class of people he considers himself better than in pursuit of economic gain he considers them unworthy of. One scene prior to the twist involves Oliver discussing his fictional parents' struggles with mental health and addiction and ends with Oliver and Felix toasting to Felix's statement of "fuck 'em".  The middle and upper class jointly celebrate the inadequacy of, not the actual working class, but their invention of what the working class is.

The revelation that Oliver isn't actually working class completely shifts his character. Oliver isn't desperate or vulnerable. He's a middle-class student at Oxford. Crucially, his life would have been absolutely fine had he never met the Cattons. So why does Oliver do what he does?

The scene immediately following Felix's death is the most powerful moment of the film. It's a stomach-churning display of grief and Oliver sits there, drowning in it, knowing he caused it. Again, Oliver didn't do this to ensure he could feed his kids or ensure he could keep a roof over his family's head. Oliver isn't getting revenge against a group of people who have made his life miserable. His life is fine.

Oliver does it because he's greedy. His pleasant and comfortable middle-class existence, which actual working-class people dream of, is not enough for him. The level of wealth the Cattons possess is completely unjustifiable and Saltburn knows this. No one should be that rich. It doesn't matter what your background is or how hard you work, and that's why Oliver can't be legitimately working-class. A film in which a legitimately working-class character befriends an evil upper-class family, is invited to their lavish home, and then burns it down would probably work, but that's not the film Emerald Fennel set out to make nor is it the story she's best equipped to tell. Oliver's desire to possess Saltburn cannot be shown as morally ambiguous, it has to be wrong.

The final scene demonstrates this. Oliver isn't relieved, he's elated. Just as Felix did when Oliver first arrived, Oliver arrogantly parades us around the various rooms of his mansion. This isn't the only parallel between Oliver and the Cattons in this scene. Fennel has an entire film in which to highlight how shamelessly the Cattons flaunt their wealth, with Pike's Elspeth being the most notorious offender. Oliver is given only one scene, but it's probably the most visceral example of shameless flaunting I've ever seen.

My initial feeling coming out of Saltburn was that it was a relatively clichéd class revenge story. I no longer think it's a class revenge story at all. Oliver has no reason to seek revenge. He doesn't hate the upper class for existing, he simply wants to be a part of it. He doesn't hate the Cattons because they're upper class, he hates them because he considers them a stain on what the upper class should be. They don't deserve their wealth, he does.

Whilst the Cattons may also be villains, Oliver is the villain. But this isn't because Emerald Fennel wants to paint the middle class as more evil than the upper class. Oliver is an individual who comes from a nice family and background. He's successful at school and gets a scholarship to one of the best universities in the country. He is perfectly set up for a great life.

But it's not enough. He's greedy. He's sociopathic. He's obsessive. He lies. He manipulates. He kills. He drives someone to suicide. He sees others around him as less than human. He bulldozes through people's lives. And he does it all for absurd wealth. Absurd power. Absurd status. Venetia is right, he is a moth drawn to shiny things. But Venetia is also very wrong, he is a spider weaving a web of traps. And the traps work. It all works. And just as in real life, there's no karma in Saltburn. What does Oliver receive for the merciless havoc he wreaks on the lives of others? More money, power, and status than any one person should ever hold.

Oliver doesn't represent the middle class, he represents becoming upper-class. Saltburn is a story about the only type of person who can make the leap from middle class to upper class, and what they will do to make that leap. As one last spit in the face, Oliver says "Unlike you, I actually know how to work." Oliver tears a family apart to gain wealth he doesn't need, then looks us dead in the eye and earnestly tells us he earned it. In true upper-class fashion, Oliver ends the film confidently stating that he owns Saltburn, not because he's evil or sociopathic or lucky or obsessive, but because he worked hard.

And how does he actually come to own Saltburn?

He fucking inherits it.

Comments